If you’re considering buying a pinball machine, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is whether to buy new or used. Both options have their unique advantages and drawbacks — and understanding these can help you make the best choice for your needs, budget, and game room.
At House of Pinball, we’ve helped thousands of customers find the perfect machine — so here’s our ultimate guide to the pros and cons of new vs. used pinball machines, designed to drive your confidence and ensure you get the best value.
Why This Choice Matters
Pinball machines are a significant investment, ranging from around $3,000 for entry-level used models to over $10,000 for premium new releases. The decision impacts not just your upfront cost but maintenance, gameplay experience, and resale value.
Choosing wisely will save you headaches and ensure years of fun.
Pros and Cons: New Pinball Machines
Pros
- Brand New Condition: Everything works perfectly with zero wear and tear. No unexpected repairs.
- Latest Technology: Newest models feature cutting-edge gameplay, enhanced LCD screens, and sound systems.
- Full Manufacturer Warranty: Peace of mind with comprehensive support and replacement parts.
- Customization Options: Some manufacturers offer customization or limited editions exclusive to new buyers.
- Higher Resale Value: New machines tend to hold value better, especially limited editions or collector’s models.
Cons
- Higher Price Tag: New pinball machines cost significantly more — often 30-50% above used equivalents.
- Longer Wait Times: Popular new releases can have backorders or production delays.
- Break-in Period: Some early-use mechanical adjustments might be needed even with new machines.
Pros and Cons: Used Pinball Machines
Pros
- Lower Initial Cost: Used machines often sell for a fraction of the new price — great for budget-conscious buyers.
- Immediate Availability: No wait time; you can usually take home a used machine quickly.
- Vintage & Classic Models: Access to rare or out-of-production pinball machines not available new.
- Tested Gameplay: Often well-played and “broken in,” so gameplay feels smooth.
Cons
- Potential Maintenance Needs: Used machines may require repairs, part replacements, or cleaning.
- Unknown History: Without a thorough inspection, previous damage or neglect might cause problems.
- No or Limited Warranty: Most used machines are sold “as-is” without manufacturer backing.
- Variable Condition: Cosmetic wear, faded artwork, or worn mechanics can impact your experience.
Key Factors to Consider When Choosing
1. Budget
- If you want the newest features and warranty, new might be worth the extra cost.
- For tight budgets or entry-level players, used can offer excellent value.
2. Gameplay & Features
- Are you chasing the latest technology, sound, and artwork? Go new.
- Looking for a classic feel or a rare theme? Used offers a wider selection.
3. Maintenance Willingness
- Do you enjoy tinkering, fixing, or restoring? Used machines can be rewarding but require effort.
- Prefer a hassle-free experience? New machines reduce surprises.
4. Resale & Investment
- New limited editions often hold or increase value over time.
- Used machines vary greatly; condition and rarity drive value.
Tips to Buy Used Pinball Machines Safely
- Buy from trusted dealers like House of Pinball who inspect and certify machines.
- Request detailed photos and maintenance records.
- Ask about warranty or return policies.
- Consider professional inspection or setup services.
- Factor in shipping and setup costs.
Why Buy Your Pinball Machine from House of Pinball?
At House of Pinball, we offer:
- A curated inventory of new and certified pre-owned pinball machines
- Transparent condition reports and expert advice
- Competitive pricing and financing options
- Full warranty and service support
- Delivery and professional setup
We are dedicated to helping you find the right pinball machine for sale — new or used — that fits your lifestyle and budget.
Conclusion: Which Should You Choose?
New pinball machines offer unmatched reliability, latest features, and peace of mind — ideal for collectors or serious players ready to invest.
Used pinball machines provide affordable options, rare finds, and opportunities for hands-on enthusiasts — perfect for those prioritizing value or vintage charm.
No matter your choice, House of Pinball is your trusted partner to ensure a smooth buying experience and lasting enjoyment.
Ready to Find Your Perfect Pinball Machine?
Browse our wide selection of new and used pinball machines for sale today and get expert guidance from the House of Pinball team.