If you’ve been eyeing a pinball machine for sale, you’ve probably asked yourself:
“Is this just a fun toy… or is it actually a smart investment?”
At House of Pinball, we’ve worked with collectors, first-time buyers, and investors for over a decade — and we’re here to give you the real answer.
Let’s break down the numbers, the facts, and what you should know before you buy.
📈 The Short Answer: Yes — But Only If You Buy the Right Machine
Like classic cars, vintage watches, or rare vinyl, pinball machines can absolutely increase in value. But not all machines are created equal.
A well-chosen machine can:
- Retain (or even grow) in value over time
- Become more collectible as supply drops
- Provide enjoyment while it appreciates
- Be resold to recoup your investment (or more)
The key? Knowing which machines to invest in and where to buy them.
💰 1. Pinball Machine Resale Values: What the Market Says
Let’s look at the resale market.
Classic and limited-edition pinball machines have seen consistent appreciation over the last 10–15 years. For example:
| Machine | Original Price | Current Value (2025) |
|---|---|---|
| Medieval Madness (1997) | ~$3,000 | $10,000–$15,000 |
| Elvira House of Horrors LE (2019) | ~$9,500 | $14,000+ |
| The Addams Family (1992) | ~$2,995 | $10,000+ |
Even recent machines like Godzilla Premium (2021) have increased in value due to demand.
👉 Bottom line: If maintained well, quality pinball machines hold value better than most electronics or home arcade gear.
🧠 2. What Makes a Pinball Machine a Good Investment?
Not all machines are “investment-grade.” Here’s what to look for:
🔥 A. Limited Editions & Collector’s Models
These are often made in runs of 500–1,000 units, with premium features and custom art. Scarcity = future demand.
🎥 B. Licensed Themes with Staying Power
Machines based on timeless pop culture (e.g., Star Wars, Marvel, Jurassic Park) tend to retain value better than original themes.
🧱 C. Build Quality & Brand Reputation
Top manufacturers like Stern, Jersey Jack Pinball, and Chicago Gaming have a proven track record.
⏱️ D. Condition & Care
A well-maintained machine with low plays and original parts will always fetch a higher price.
✅ TIP: Machines kept in homes tend to appreciate more than those used in commercial locations due to lower wear and tear.
🛠️ 3. Can You Make Money Operating a Pinball Machine?
Yes — if you’re thinking about monetizing your machine, it’s totally possible.
Common options include:
- Hosting tournaments and game nights
- Setting up in local bars or arcades for revenue share
- Renting out machines for events
While it won’t replace your 9-to-5, it’s not uncommon to make $50–$200/month per machine in the right setting — while still owning the asset.
🏠 4. Home Use = Long-Term Value
Even if you’re not buying for resale, a pinball machine is an investment in entertainment.
- No subscription fees
- No internet connection required
- Lasts for decades
- Increases the value of your game room or man cave
Think of it as a fun asset — something you can use and resell later.
🧾 5. Tax Benefits & Depreciation (for Business Use)
Buying a machine for your:
- Arcade
- Bar or restaurant
- Office break room
- Airbnb property
…could potentially qualify for business depreciation under U.S. tax law.
Always speak to a tax advisor — but yes, pinball can be a legitimate business investment.
❓ Should You Buy New or Used?
Both can be solid investments. Here’s how to decide:
| Buy New If… | Buy Used If… |
|---|---|
| You want a warranty & tech support | You want a lower upfront cost |
| You’re a first-time buyer | You’re comfortable inspecting machines |
| You’re buying a recent limited edition | You want a classic that’s no longer made |
At House of Pinball, we stock both new and certified pre-owned machines — all backed with expert support.
🛒 What Pinball Machine Should You Buy?
Looking for your first or next pinball investment? Here are top picks by category:
✅ Best Investment Picks (2025)
| Machine | Why It’s a Smart Buy |
|---|---|
| Godzilla Premium | High demand + great gameplay |
| The Mandalorian LE | Star Wars universe + limited run |
| Deadpool Pro | Fan favorite with strong resale |
| Elvira House of Horrors LE | Cult classic appeal |
👉 Browse our latest pinball machines for sale and filter by price, theme, or edition.
🔐 Buying from a Trusted Seller = A Smarter Investment
When buying for investment, where you buy matters just as much as what you buy.
Why Buy From House of Pinball?
- 🛠️ Every machine is inspected, cleaned & certified
- 📦 Secure shipping nationwide
- 🔧 Lifetime tech support
- 🧠 Expert advice from collectors and technicians
- 💵 Trade-in options available
Don’t risk buying from shady resellers or auction sites. We offer full transparency, support, and service.
💬 Final Thoughts: A Fun Hobby That Can Pay Off
Yes — pinball machines can be a great investment when you choose the right model and care for it properly.
But perhaps the greatest ROI isn’t financial — it’s in the joy, nostalgia, and connection these machines create in your home or business.
When you’re ready to explore the best pinball machines for sale, we’re here to help you invest wisely.